How to study physics? (Question for students and instructors)

  • #1
gimak
56
1
Hello, I've been pondering this question for many years now and I've finally believe I've discovered the answer. The answer is to adopt a set of study strategies that force you to deeply ponder physics as much as possible. I'll explain. When many students first start out studying physics, they think just by passively listening to lectures and reading textbooks they'll pass the class. Unfortunately, they're wrong and end up failing the course.

A better idea would be the following. Let's assume the worst-case scenario. Let's assume that a student has low-level math and academic skills and their physics teacher is bad. Unfortunately, their odds of success are low, unless they do the following. Before lecture, they read the textbook with a set of guided reading questions to keep them attentive and try to work out as many of the book's example problems as possible. After lecture, they go to a classmate or a tutor and ask any questions they have on the lecture or textbook. Then, they try the homework problems and ask questions. Through this process, they either get the help they need or decide their math skills are too low and drop the course to take a lower-level math class.

Note: different things work for different people. Maybe the textbook has nothing to do with the lectures so they ditch the textbook completely and instead use internet website that more completely align with lectures. Or maybe the lectures have nothing to do with the test so they skip lectures and use the textbook and/or internet. The point is to think deeply about principles. A person's study strategies and study plans can be judged by how well they make students think deeply about things.

Again for some physics teachers, some don't make you think as deeply and you can pass their class by just understanding their problems and homework. However, others make you think so deeply about things that they expect you to jump from 1D-kinematics to 2D-projectile motion with no preparation whatsoever. Perhaps it's best to avoid teachers who make you think TOO deeply and who don't make you think deeply enough.

As far as measuring someone's physics understanding, there are degrees to this. People who just memorize problems and solutions have a low level of understanding. People who can do problems with the numbers changed and can do math with no physical intuition and without recognizing the assumptions we're making when solving said problems have an intermediate understanding. People who can do problems with understanding the math and physical reality have an advanced understanding.

What are your thoughts? Do you disagree?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
My thoughts are that it takes two to tango. A good teacher cannot teach a student who doesn't care about learning. Conversely, a student who cares about learning will learn despite having a bad teacher. The remedies that you propose cannot be imposed from the outside and will work only if the student is motivated to find ways for improvement. I addressed the motivation issue here.
 
  • Like
Likes Math100
  • #3
kuruman said:
My thoughts are that it takes two to tango. A good teacher cannot teach a student who doesn't care about learning. Conversely, a student who cares about learning will learn despite having a bad teacher. The remedies that you propose cannot be imposed from the outside and will work only if the student is motivated to find ways for improvement. I addressed the motivation issue here.
Hmm... A student who's never had a good teacher though,or is the product of a terrible system may not learn despite his/her best efforts. But, I agree with you to a certain extent. Too many students blame the teachers/the system when they themselves need to be responsibility. But, I'm certain there's a sizeable minority of students who take responsibility but have never been taught how to learn due to a broken system. We should keep in mind this minority too. But besides my bad teacher rant, do you agree with everything else?
 
  • Like
Likes hutchphd
  • #4
It is hard to argue with some of your points. If you have a bad (or even a good) teacher, you will benefit from studying the material, asking (knowing) classmates, or preferably tutors, about points you don't understand, and doing as many homework problems as possible. As far as ditching the lectures if they do not help in the tests, you never know if the lectures are useful, until you take the first tests. After a few tests, it can be too late. In addition, many good teachers of mine used to put questions they addressed in class on the tests. Lectures, generally told us what they regarded as important.

There was also a general rule of thumb, "Never skip the lecture right before the test". I had a teacher once who told us the last years test was very similar, and he put it on reserve in the reading room. The class average on the test was an 82. I did not attend the lecture, and my score was a 28. (I did not skip four more classes as an undergrad ( in the remaining 3 years) after this. And two of these skipped, were after I was in a car that was totalled) . He told me if he made the other tests as easy, he could flunk me right there, after the first test. I had to work like a dog to bring my average up to a C. It is a good thing he made the other tests much harder.
 

1. How can I improve my understanding of physics?

One of the best ways to improve your understanding of physics is to practice regularly. This can include solving practice problems, participating in group discussions, and reviewing class notes. Additionally, seeking help from your instructor or a tutor can also greatly enhance your understanding.

2. What study techniques are most effective for learning physics?

Effective study techniques for physics often involve a combination of active learning and understanding concepts rather than simply memorizing formulas. This can include taking thorough notes, creating concept maps, and practicing problem-solving.

3. How much time should I spend studying physics?

The amount of time needed to study physics can vary for each individual, but it is generally recommended to spend at least 2-3 hours outside of class for every hour spent in class. It is important to find a study schedule that works for you and to prioritize your time effectively.

4. How can I prepare for physics exams?

To prepare for physics exams, it is important to review class materials regularly and practice solving problems. Additionally, creating a study guide or summarizing key concepts can also be helpful. It is also important to get enough rest and stay organized leading up to the exam.

5. What resources are available to help me study physics?

There are many resources available to help students study physics. These can include textbooks, online resources, study groups, and tutoring services. Additionally, many instructors offer office hours or extra help sessions for students who need additional support.

Similar threads

  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
19
Views
4K
Replies
22
Views
787
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • STEM Educators and Teaching
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
10
Views
819
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top