Dune: "Fremen Attack Tactic"

• Mar 1, 2021

• #1

Whitestar

90

4

In Sci-Fi Channel's "Dune", there is a scene in which the Fremen attack Gurney Halleck and his men in a really cool fashion: They pop up from the sand and attack them.

Here is a clip of that scene:

I would imagine that for this to work, an oxygen mask would be required, at the very least.

My question is, how realistic is this type of attack? That is, how could such an attack tactic work in real life such as popping up from the sand? Would it require the aid of some kind of technology or is this pure fantasy?

 

Physics news on Phys.org

• Research suggests how turbulence can be used to generate patterns
• High-quality microwave signals generated from tiny photonic chip
• Quantum talk with magnetic disks

• Mar 2, 2021

• #2

Rive

Science Advisor

2,919

2,337

Whitestar said:

My question is, how realistic is this type of attack?

Not realistic at all. The movie is ~ from the same years when it was about ninjas popping up from everywhere: from the ground, from the woods, from thin air. It's the same.

Some camouflage might be possible, but for that you better reference the Lord of the Rings movie instead:

 

• Mar 1, 2022

• #3

AlexTheParticle

228

1

Well, in the world of Dune, the Fremen are highly skilled and trained warriors who have adapted to the harsh desert environment of the planet Arrakis. They have developed techniques and technology that allow them to move swiftly and silently through the sand, making it possible for them to "pop up" and surprise their enemies.

In real life, such an attack would definitely require some kind of technology and equipment. It's not something that could be done by a person alone. In fact, in the Dune novels, the Fremen use specialized stillsuits and sandworm hooks to navigate through the sand.

That being said, there are some real-life examples of similar tactics being used in warfare. For example, in the Afghan-Soviet War, the Mujahideen fighters used a tactic called "burrowing" where they would dig tunnels and pop up to attack Soviet troops. However, this was a much slower and less dramatic version of the Fremen's sand attack.

So, while the Fremen's attack in Dune may be a bit exaggerated and fantastical, there are some elements of realism to it. With the right technology and training, a similar tactic could potentially be used in real life. But for now, it remains a cool and impressive scene in the sci-fi world.

 

1. What is the "Fremen Attack Tactic" in Dune?

The "Fremen Attack Tactic" is a military strategy used by the Fremen, a group of desert-dwelling people on the planet Arrakis in the science fiction novel Dune by Frank Herbert. It involves using surprise attacks, guerrilla warfare, and knowledge of the harsh desert environment to defeat their enemies.

2. How do the Fremen use the desert environment to their advantage in their attack tactic?

The Fremen are able to navigate and survive in the harsh desert environment of Arrakis, giving them a unique advantage in battle. They use their knowledge of the terrain to launch surprise attacks and disappear quickly, making it difficult for their enemies to track them.

3. What makes the "Fremen Attack Tactic" effective against their enemies?

The "Fremen Attack Tactic" is effective because it is based on the principles of guerrilla warfare, which involves using unconventional tactics to defeat a larger and more powerful enemy. The Fremen are also highly skilled fighters and have a deep understanding of their environment, making them formidable opponents.

4. Who are the Fremen in Dune and why do they use this attack tactic?

The Fremen are a group of people who have adapted to the harsh environment of Arrakis and formed a strong, self-sufficient community. They use the "Fremen Attack Tactic" to defend their way of life and protect their resources from outsiders who seek to exploit them.

5. Are there any weaknesses or limitations to the "Fremen Attack Tactic"?

While the "Fremen Attack Tactic" is highly effective against their enemies, it does have some limitations. The Fremen are limited by their small numbers and lack of advanced technology, making it difficult for them to engage in large-scale battles. They also rely heavily on the unpredictable desert environment, which can sometimes work against them.